Выбранный диапазон Имя файла C:\Documents and Settings\Миша\Мои документы\Bobby Timmons - Soul Time\Bobby Timmons - Soul Time.wav Пиковый уровень 100.0 % Качество диапазона 100.0 % CRC копии 18895AB4 Копирование... OK Ошибок не произошло
Selected range Filename J:\eMusic\Rip\Herbie Mann - Returns To The Village Gate.wav Peak level 98.5 % Range quality 99.9 % Test CRC 3697F39C Copy CRC 3697F39C Copy OK No errors occurred
Track 2 Filename F:\EAC Rips\Leon Redbone - Red To Blue\02 - Lovesick Blues.wav Pre-gap length 0:00:01.28 Peak level 89.5 % Track quality 100.0 % Test CRC 0B95E6B8 Copy CRC 0B95E6B8 Accurately ripped (confidence 1) [BA94421F] Copy OK
Если пиковые уровни отличаются -- мы имеем на руках два разных мастеринга (обсуждение некоторых тонкостей можно найти здесь). В большинстве разделов модераторы в таком случае оставляют оба релиза. Если пиковые уровни совпадают -- оба издания мастерингом не отличаются. Тем не менее кое-какими мелочами они отличаться могут. К этому мы сейчас и перейдем. Прежде всего, если в обоих логах имеются ТОС (Table Of Content), их стоит сравнить (в старых версиях ЕАС ТОС отсутствует, поэтому это сравнение не всегда можно сделать). Если ТОС различаются -- чаще всего это два разных издания, хотя различаются они не сильно. Могут, например, слегка отличаться зазоры между треками (в том числе, не тихие зазоры, т.е. содержащие музыку, разговор и т.д.). Если ТОС совпадают, то отличие альбомов может быть только в общем смещении (то есть эти альбомы печатались с одной матрицы, но штамповки могут отличаться, если они пришли с разных заводов -- каждый завод вносит свое индивидуальное смещение), а вот рипы могут слегка отличаться. Например, если в одном из рипов имелись ошибки, которые ЕАС не отметил в логе (так бывает) или если смещения приводов, на которых эти два рипа делались, различаются, а ненулевое содержание имеется на диске до самого конца. Итак, различие ТОС означает некоторое отличие альбомов, следовательно, модератор имеет возможность признать музыкальное содержание рипов различающимся. Если же ТОС совпадают, то ленивый модератор (вроде меня) может засчитать повтор и подождать, не приведет ли настойчивый релизер доказательств обратного. Какие же должны быть более аккуратные проверки? Ну, прежде всего, можно просто сравнить контрольные суммы CRC. Если они совпали (в случае потрекового рипа совпали для всех треков), у нас имеется две точные, бит-в-бит копии музыкального содержимого. Такая раздача должна несомненно быть закрыта как повтор. Внимание! Бывает случай, когда CRC отличаются для одного и того же издания, но разных приводов -- когда ненулевые сэмплы имеются до самого конца диска. Тогда приводы с разным смещением дадут разные CRC, но отличаться будет только последний трек. Это -- повтор, поскольку в противном случае пришлось бы на каждое значение смещения привода разрешить свой рип одного и того же альбома. К сожалению, метод сравнения CRC проходит не всегда. Во-первых, часто в одном рипе треки, в другом образ. Во-вторых, даже у двух "правильных" рипов, например, образом контрольные суммы этого образа могут различаться (более того, если в одном из рипов в строке лога про учет нулевых сэмплов стоит "Нет", а в другом "Да", контрольные суммы будут отличаться с гарантией). Как же быть? Ответ простой -- надо сравнить результаты аккуратрипа (сокращенно АР -- accuraterip). Проще всего, если они есть прямо в логах ЕАС. Вот пример:
Имя файла C:\Documents and Settings\Viktor\Мои документы\Моя музыка\Queen - A Night At The Opera.wav Пиковый уровень 95.6 % Качество диапазона 100.0 % CRC теста 86DECA37 CRC копии 86DECA37 Копирование... OK Ошибок не произошло AccurateRip: сводка Трек 1 точное извлечение (доверие 110) [CE835707] Трек 2 точное извлечение (доверие 111) [E020B368] Трек 3 точное извлечение (доверие 112) [9914C84D] Трек 4 точное извлечение (доверие 112) [C6E3D98D] Трек 5 точное извлечение (доверие 111) [750394FA] Трек 6 точное извлечение (доверие 109) [8E295391] Трек 7 точное извлечение (доверие 109) [A9F4F5B4] Трек 8 точное извлечение (доверие 111) [872A300C] Трек 9 точное извлечение (доверие 110) [B8356D16] Трек 10 точное извлечение (доверие 109) [FACF45A3] Трек 11 точное извлечение (доверие 112) [BA4FB4DD] Трек 12 точное извлечение (доверие 104) [36C1448D] Все треки извлечены точно Конец отчёта
Выбранный диапазон Имя файла D:\Queen 1975\Queen (p) 1975 - A Night At The Opera.wav Пиковый уровень 95.6 % Качество диапазона 100.0 % CRC теста 151EE6F6 CRC копии 151EE6F6 Копирование... OK Ошибок не произошло AccurateRip: сводка Трек 1 точное извлечение (доверие 183) [CE835707] Трек 2 точное извлечение (доверие 185) [E020B368] Трек 3 точное извлечение (доверие 187) [9914C84D] Трек 4 точное извлечение (доверие 185) [C6E3D98D] Трек 5 точное извлечение (доверие 185) [750394FA] Трек 6 точное извлечение (доверие 183) [8E295391] Трек 7 точное извлечение (доверие 183) [A9F4F5B4] Трек 8 точное извлечение (доверие 185) [872A300C] Трек 9 точное извлечение (доверие 184) [B8356D16] Трек 10 точное извлечение (доверие 183) [FACF45A3] Трек 11 точное извлечение (доверие 187) [BA4FB4DD] Трек 12 точное извлечение (доверие 178) [36C1448D] Все треки извлечены точно Конец отчёта
Видно, что CRC треков, которые определил АР, совпадают. Таким образом, мы имеем точный повтор. Внимание: CRC треков в потрековом релизе и CRC треков, которые выдает АР, всегда отличаются, потому что считаются разными способами. Кроме того, CRC для АР считается для первого трека альбома без первых 4 блоков по 588 сэмплов, для последнего трека без последних 5-ти блоков. Для треков из "середины" используются все сэмплы. Так что, формально говоря, мы имеем повтор только с точностью до этих отброшенных сэмплов. Однако, вероятность косяков именно в этих сэмплах мала. Часто, однако, в одном (или в обоих) из логов нет проверки АР. Вот тогда надо либо попросить пользователя проверить рип по базе АР при помощи программы CueTools (см. также здесь комментарии к тому, как читать отчет CueTools), либо проделать это самому. Результаты, которые выдает CueTools, на самом деле, горазо информативнее проверки по базе АР ЕАСом. Среди прочего, даже если диска в базе нет, CueTools выдаст CRC треков в формате, приспособленном для сравнения с базой АР и, прогнав оба рипа через CueTools, можно будет сравнить соответствующие CRC. Лог проверки CueTools выглядит примерно так:
[Verification date: 07.01.2011 17:25:24] [Disc ID: 002b3c36-02424fb7-080f3512] HDCD: peak extend: none, transient filter: some, gain: none Track [ CRC ] Status 01 [3821a266] (04/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 02 [1ed54beb] (04/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 03 [4da31f1a] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 04 [13c792ca] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 05 [a0041255] (04/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 06 [600f049d] (04/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 07 [0c51193e] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 08 [02a1ac1a] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 09 [2af9df2a] (04/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 10 [4c37575c] (04/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 11 [5002174f] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 12 [ab49bdee] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 13 [ecd2a7eb] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 14 [d754fef3] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 15 [2dace099] (04/25) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 16 [931baeeb] (04/24) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 17 [5b1c6c4d] (04/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 18 [cae80a19] (04/25) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #2 Offsetted by 664: 01 [401fd239] (23/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 02 [f768548e] (23/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 03 [f6087fad] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 04 [e8c79bd4] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 05 [2e49714c] (23/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 06 [895d94c8] (23/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 07 [43af3b42] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 08 [65dd418c] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 09 [32cb132d] (23/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 10 [67a67a1d] (23/27) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 11 [2b885175] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 12 [d662889d] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 13 [2fd73b9a] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 14 [a7bc2760] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 15 [67c35220] (21/25) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 16 [11986740] (20/24) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 17 [867275ee] (22/26) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 18 [60be1d4e] (21/25) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #1 Track [ CRC32 ] [W/O NULL] -- [CA18EC09] [98E196F3] 01 [A9264C04] [E0C4EB19] 02 [8098CFA4] [6168C2FF] 03 [C69A39CC] [B0D996ED] 04 [B8A150EA] [67633D0D] 05 [8E0C5E60] [E97005D2] 06 [1CC0FCCC] [688BCC0D] 07 [B9A9683C] [C0A02F23] 08 [EB3A6E91] [6F707D7C] 09 [F85EAA1B] [07E0C10D] 10 [9AF074A4] [656B7DE8] 11 [81B40461] [28EC215C] 12 [26D5CF77] [DFB51A93] 13 [83143E3A] [A06143EF] 14 [36F497F3] [709D9B24] 15 [CB252DED] [6C2A9535] 16 [A1904459] [B15C6449] 17 [D50700BB] [1EFE4D41] 18 [24BEAF47] [7BCE30C3]
Здесь не просто указаны CRC треков, но указаны также CRC треков при значениях оффсетов (смещений), отвечающих различным штамповкам данного диска, имеющимся в базе АР. Это важно, поскольку часто бывает так, что рипы таки тождественны, но делались с дисков, отличающихся смещением (то есть с дисков, сделанных на разных заводах с одной матрицы). И вот этот факт CueTools позволяет обнаружить (если, конечно, диск с нужным смещением вообще нашелся в базе). В указанном примере при смещении на 664 CRC совпадают с результатами АР вот этого рипа:
То есть это опять точный повтор. Здесь, однако, надо иметь в виду, что если в базе АР имеется слишком много вариантов диска с разными смещениями, то CueTools показывает их не все. Вот пример логов СueTools двух идентичных дисков:
[Verification date: 20.01.2011 13:57:20] [Disc ID: 0030209b-025fb921-ec11cd11] Pregap length 00:00:32. Track [ CRC ] Status 01 [a43fcdb0] (00/1697) No matches 02 [9037e309] (00/1701) No matches 03 [44c4f94e] (00/1697) No matches 04 [aa3a5fb1] (00/1693) No matches 05 [8d05e028] (00/1695) No matches 06 [2f4086c7] (00/1686) No matches 07 [87a012fc] (00/1690) No matches 08 [6bda9d11] (00/1685) No matches 09 [0f611caf] (00/1679) No matches 10 [6389b62c] (00/1679) No matches 11 [467c36f2] (00/1668) No matches 12 [9fc1303c] (00/1671) No matches 13 [ae61de76] (00/1666) No matches 14 [b50c6b0a] (00/1679) No matches 15 [871518f0] (00/1671) No matches 16 [f9973c10] (00/1662) No matches 17 [09433720] (00/1636) No matches Offsetted by -128: 01 [47b3adb0] (36/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 02 [8bbf4709] (36/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 03 [aad44a4e] (36/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 04 [3670cccd] (36/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 05 [0d5db0fc] (36/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 06 [0566bdc7] (35/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 07 [ea67faa1] (36/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 08 [a36074a3] (35/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 09 [0c1d9bf8] (36/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 10 [7c50e2e3] (35/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 11 [7744a1fb] (35/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 12 [9bb1eac2] (35/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 13 [a189d0c4] (34/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 14 [b0db70cb] (37/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 15 [0f1ed2a8] (37/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 16 [7663e8cb] (36/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 17 [c9b19f20] (36/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 Offsetted by -107: 01 [dae2aaf0] (05/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 02 [cb26baa1] (05/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 03 [a4068504] (05/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 04 [d42df09d] (05/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 05 [2f914d0f] (05/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 06 [a04478c1] (05/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 07 [50320416] (05/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 08 [5502aad4] (05/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 09 [50b8af97] (05/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 10 [752ee0df] (05/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 11 [5aa8d2db] (05/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 12 [85ff0616] (05/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 13 [462e0754] (05/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 14 [087e0cf1] (05/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 15 [89e08fda] (05/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 16 [b95e91a7] (05/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 17 [661f8210] (05/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 Offsetted by 116: 01 [881ecab0] (06/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 02 [facf69be] (06/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 03 [5066d02d] (06/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 04 [485951e6] (06/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 05 [a5f36b2b] (06/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 06 [252de4ef] (06/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 07 [645a5f5a] (06/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 08 [5210976f] (06/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 09 [391c7aa7] (06/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 10 [4a8c3ac5] (06/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 11 [ba8909c9] (06/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 12 [2f601de3] (06/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 13 [7e253483] (06/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 14 [cf1a2583] (06/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 15 [6c236108] (06/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 16 [7ff0be83] (06/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 17 [cadf28e0] (06/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 Offsetted by 173: 01 [855530f0] (06/1697) Partial match to pressing(s) #32 02 [65f910fd] (06/1701) Partial match to pressing(s) #32 03 [f50c9454] (03/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 04 [1f7733a4] (03/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 05 [ce285ccc] (03/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #39 06 [5bd0e071] (03/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 07 [50d17d5e] (03/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #41 08 [498eb91e] (03/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 09 [8908021d] (03/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 10 [80466c92] (03/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 11 [ba93b8a8] (03/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #39 12 [4ddafeac] (03/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #41 13 [cdc377a2] (03/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 14 [027f9a47] (03/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 15 [79e6723b] (02/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 16 [3821383c] (06/1662) Partial match to pressing(s) #32 17 [e12dfe90] (05/1636) Partial match to pressing(s) #34 Offsetted by 239: 01 [9d0d7170] (19/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 02 [c74dc52b] (20/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 03 [04edbad2] (19/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 04 [201f474d] (19/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 05 [b3715fc1] (19/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 06 [f9652c15] (19/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 07 [814ca0fa] (19/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 08 [cbd930a8] (19/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 09 [534a9c19] (19/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 10 [16986115] (19/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 11 [6d3505fd] (18/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 12 [8476c020] (18/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 13 [888a3b4e] (19/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 14 [29ee6ed9] (19/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 15 [87112918] (18/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 16 [46789e49] (18/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 17 [15f510f0] (19/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 Offsetted by 506: 01 [5a19bc30] (25/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 02 [5806ef88] (27/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 03 [6868cae7] (27/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 04 [3af9fd16] (25/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 05 [d1555b79] (26/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 06 [3cb1755b] (24/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 07 [620f299e] (25/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 08 [b6b1a225] (25/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 09 [3e7ff1d3] (24/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 10 [1196390e] (26/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 11 [e24f5368] (24/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 12 [c1f1c9c2] (25/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 13 [3fc85d40] (25/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 14 [ec5087a6] (26/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 15 [b225e438] (25/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 16 [858f3e48] (25/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 17 [488ec400] (24/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 Offsetted by 660: 01 [917252b0] (03/1697) Partial match to pressing(s) #37 02 [d1da3e9e] (02/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 03 [e2fc7a0d] (02/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 04 [4f007cd1] (02/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 05 [774a289c] (02/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 06 [570b7b2f] (02/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 07 [ae38d313] (02/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #54 08 [910ef89a] (02/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 09 [2454b963] (02/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 10 [1f5c6542] (02/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 11 [c6aeb96c] (02/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 12 [ef0a49a8] (02/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 13 [f45d5e02] (02/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 14 [bb77fe1a] (02/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #54 15 [9cf00149] (02/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 16 [ce94fd0b] (02/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 17 [1909eee0] (02/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 Offsetted by 703: 01 [2c896570] (47/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 02 [6b8e98db] (46/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 03 [37151702] (46/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 04 [4aed0d66] (46/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 05 [8324d9fc] (45/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 06 [d11aa4b5] (45/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 07 [6a258ea3] (43/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 08 [1efc2f50] (44/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 09 [0c35e118] (45/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 10 [f441c9be] (44/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 11 [da951ab4] (44/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 12 [f033759b] (44/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 13 [d8531c43] (44/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 14 [43957348] (45/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 15 [87d2f527] (44/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 16 [834f1337] (44/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 17 [1c64d7f0] (41/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 Offsetted by 709: 01 [e8dff6f0] (97/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 02 [0fe34c25] (98/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 03 [7e5a033c] (97/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 04 [30a90817] (97/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 05 [ae868d35] (96/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 06 [6b10da21] (96/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 07 [f7666797] (96/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 08 [d27918ae] (96/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 09 [5b973f6c] (93/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 10 [a0b881a6] (96/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 11 [882fd4d4] (94/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 12 [fe9a8563] (92/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 13 [7517724f] (94/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 14 [dd4d528c] (95/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 15 [1a008149] (92/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 16 [66965739] (93/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 17 [db5fab10] (86/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 Offsetted by 731: 01 [f0c80c70] (72/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 02 [18e632df] (71/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #8 03 [d8ee6566] (72/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 04 [2f2d4599] (73/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #8 05 [a357c7f1] (74/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 06 [4a4248ad] (73/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 07 [9ccee2f3] (72/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 08 [e95a6714] (72/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #8 09 [28af97e0] (73/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 10 [234e9dbb] (72/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 11 [ac1b2b37] (72/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 12 [1025213b] (73/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 13 [b40302d7] (73/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 14 [988fcc46] (73/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 15 [05f51535] (73/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 16 [fc5ffa6b] (71/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 17 [424cb130] (70/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 Offsetted by 732: 01 [658124b0] (26/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 02 [344aa616] (27/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 03 [3a238cc5] (26/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 04 [12e90789] (27/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 05 [7ff09064] (27/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 06 [8e95fc3f] (26/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 07 [df035c72] (26/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 08 [13ff376e] (25/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 09 [e0892778] (26/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 10 [f64023ac] (27/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 11 [f36f7502] (27/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #15 12 [ee27730b] (27/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 13 [4e24667f] (27/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 14 [68c96762] (27/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 15 [cb2e5b8b] (27/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 16 [77853059] (26/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 17 [0ccbd460] (25/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 More than 10 offsets match! Track [ CRC32 ] [W/O NULL] -- [3EA30476] [32512FBA] 01 [6B9AA6AB] [04B509CB] 02 [C946F2FB] [E06A7DAF] 03 [79117EE5] [E12ECF5A] 04 [E56986F6] [D250108E] 05 [FEB20F3E] [709ED18D] 06 [B59887FA] [D147A1DE] 07 [1145755C] [34BCF284] 08 [840D9262] [B92DC921] 09 [5EBB5294] [B9C3D1DD] 10 [64E2D682] [E9A207DA] 11 [EDE85F2E] [70292C39] 12 [7481539C] [9CFF902D] 13 [454C00CF] [F93C6B08] 14 [08BB7060] [295F38DB] 15 [4F3A85D9] [6D02A290] 16 [DDC39529] [6BE07ECA] 17 [5E2ACC2F] [D23D103F]
[Verification date: 20.01.2011 18:59:25] [Disc ID: 0030209b-025fb921-ec11cd11] Pregap length 00:00:32. Track [ CRC ] Status 01 [4835b0b0] (200/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 02 [57204066] (200/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 03 [741aee95] (200/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 04 [4c7ca196] (200/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 05 [dab02407] (200/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 06 [5e47a79f] (200/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 07 [1b335922] (200/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 08 [36842d52] (200/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 09 [54480e94] (200/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 10 [a8ffd700] (200/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 11 [4aa746ae] (200/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 12 [20955e7a] (200/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 13 [33dd15a0] (200/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 14 [ad46a08b] (200/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 15 [de39a862] (200/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 16 [8cf248c1] (200/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 17 [04a26d60] (200/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #3 Offsetted by -908: 01 [47b3adb0] (36/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 02 [8bbf4709] (36/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 03 [aad44a4e] (36/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 04 [3670cccd] (36/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 05 [0d5db0fc] (36/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 06 [0566bdc7] (35/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 07 [ea67faa1] (36/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 08 [a36074a3] (35/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 09 [0c1d9bf8] (36/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 10 [7c50e2e3] (35/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 11 [7744a1fb] (35/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 12 [9bb1eac2] (35/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 13 [a189d0c4] (34/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #13 14 [b0db70cb] (37/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 15 [0f1ed2a8] (37/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 16 [7663e8cb] (36/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 17 [c9b19f20] (36/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #12 Offsetted by -887: 01 [dae2aaf0] (05/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 02 [cb26baa1] (05/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 03 [a4068504] (05/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 04 [d42df09d] (05/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 05 [2f914d0f] (05/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 06 [a04478c1] (05/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #35 07 [50320416] (05/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 08 [5502aad4] (05/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 09 [50b8af97] (05/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 10 [752ee0df] (05/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 11 [5aa8d2db] (05/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 12 [85ff0616] (05/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 13 [462e0754] (05/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 14 [087e0cf1] (05/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 15 [89e08fda] (05/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #34 16 [b95e91a7] (05/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 17 [661f8210] (05/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #33 Offsetted by -664: 01 [881ecab0] (06/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 02 [facf69be] (06/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 03 [5066d02d] (06/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 04 [485951e6] (06/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 05 [a5f36b2b] (06/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 06 [252de4ef] (06/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 07 [645a5f5a] (06/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 08 [5210976f] (06/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 09 [391c7aa7] (06/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 10 [4a8c3ac5] (06/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 11 [ba8909c9] (06/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 12 [2f601de3] (06/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 13 [7e253483] (06/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 14 [cf1a2583] (06/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 15 [6c236108] (06/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #31 16 [7ff0be83] (06/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 17 [cadf28e0] (06/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #30 Offsetted by -607: 01 [855530f0] (06/1697) Partial match to pressing(s) #32 02 [65f910fd] (06/1701) Partial match to pressing(s) #32 03 [f50c9454] (03/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 04 [1f7733a4] (03/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 05 [ce285ccc] (03/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #39 06 [5bd0e071] (03/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 07 [50d17d5e] (03/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #41 08 [498eb91e] (03/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 09 [8908021d] (03/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 10 [80466c92] (03/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 11 [ba93b8a8] (03/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #39 12 [4ddafeac] (03/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #41 13 [cdc377a2] (03/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 14 [027f9a47] (03/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #40 15 [79e6723b] (02/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 16 [3821383c] (06/1662) Partial match to pressing(s) #32 17 [e12dfe90] (05/1636) Partial match to pressing(s) #34 Offsetted by -541: 01 [9d0d7170] (19/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 02 [c74dc52b] (20/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 03 [04edbad2] (19/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 04 [201f474d] (19/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 05 [b3715fc1] (19/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 06 [f9652c15] (19/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 07 [814ca0fa] (19/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 08 [cbd930a8] (19/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 09 [534a9c19] (19/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 10 [16986115] (19/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 11 [6d3505fd] (18/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 12 [8476c020] (18/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 13 [888a3b4e] (19/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 14 [29ee6ed9] (19/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 15 [87112918] (18/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 16 [46789e49] (18/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 17 [15f510f0] (19/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #20 Offsetted by -274: 01 [5a19bc30] (25/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 02 [5806ef88] (27/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 03 [6868cae7] (27/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 04 [3af9fd16] (25/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 05 [d1555b79] (26/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 06 [3cb1755b] (24/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 07 [620f299e] (25/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 08 [b6b1a225] (25/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 09 [3e7ff1d3] (24/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 10 [1196390e] (26/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 11 [e24f5368] (24/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 12 [c1f1c9c2] (25/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 13 [3fc85d40] (25/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 14 [ec5087a6] (26/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 15 [b225e438] (25/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 16 [858f3e48] (25/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 17 [488ec400] (24/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 Offsetted by -120: 01 [917252b0] (03/1697) Partial match to pressing(s) #37 02 [d1da3e9e] (02/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 03 [e2fc7a0d] (02/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 04 [4f007cd1] (02/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 05 [774a289c] (02/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 06 [570b7b2f] (02/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 07 [ae38d313] (02/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #54 08 [910ef89a] (02/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 09 [2454b963] (02/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 10 [1f5c6542] (02/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 11 [c6aeb96c] (02/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 12 [ef0a49a8] (02/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 13 [f45d5e02] (02/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 14 [bb77fe1a] (02/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #54 15 [9cf00149] (02/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #52 16 [ce94fd0b] (02/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 17 [1909eee0] (02/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #53 Offsetted by -77: 01 [2c896570] (47/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 02 [6b8e98db] (46/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 03 [37151702] (46/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 04 [4aed0d66] (46/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 05 [8324d9fc] (45/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 06 [d11aa4b5] (45/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 07 [6a258ea3] (43/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 08 [1efc2f50] (44/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 09 [0c35e118] (45/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 10 [f441c9be] (44/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 11 [da951ab4] (44/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 12 [f033759b] (44/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 13 [d8531c43] (44/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 14 [43957348] (45/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 15 [87d2f527] (44/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 16 [834f1337] (44/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #10 17 [1c64d7f0] (41/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #11 Offsetted by -71: 01 [e8dff6f0] (97/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 02 [0fe34c25] (98/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 03 [7e5a033c] (97/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 04 [30a90817] (97/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 05 [ae868d35] (96/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 06 [6b10da21] (96/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 07 [f7666797] (96/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 08 [d27918ae] (96/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 09 [5b973f6c] (93/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 10 [a0b881a6] (96/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 11 [882fd4d4] (94/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 12 [fe9a8563] (92/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 13 [7517724f] (94/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 14 [dd4d528c] (95/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 15 [1a008149] (92/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 16 [66965739] (93/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 17 [db5fab10] (86/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #5 Offsetted by -49: 01 [f0c80c70] (72/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 02 [18e632df] (71/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #8 03 [d8ee6566] (72/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 04 [2f2d4599] (73/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #8 05 [a357c7f1] (74/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 06 [4a4248ad] (73/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 07 [9ccee2f3] (72/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 08 [e95a6714] (72/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #8 09 [28af97e0] (73/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 10 [234e9dbb] (72/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 11 [ac1b2b37] (72/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 12 [1025213b] (73/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 13 [b40302d7] (73/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 14 [988fcc46] (73/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 15 [05f51535] (73/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 16 [fc5ffa6b] (71/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 17 [424cb130] (70/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #7 Offsetted by -48: 01 [658124b0] (26/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 02 [344aa616] (27/1701) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 03 [3a238cc5] (26/1697) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #17 04 [12e90789] (27/1693) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 05 [7ff09064] (27/1695) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 06 [8e95fc3f] (26/1686) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 07 [df035c72] (26/1690) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 08 [13ff376e] (25/1685) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 09 [e0892778] (26/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 10 [f64023ac] (27/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 11 [f36f7502] (27/1668) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #15 12 [ee27730b] (27/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 13 [4e24667f] (27/1666) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 14 [68c96762] (27/1679) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 15 [cb2e5b8b] (27/1671) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 16 [77853059] (26/1662) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 17 [0ccbd460] (25/1636) Accurately ripped as in pressing(s) #16 More than 10 offsets match! Track [ CRC32 ] [W/O NULL] [ LOG ] -- [5CC5C54D] [32512FBA] CRC32 01 [FB3C86C7] [04B509CB] 02 [6BC5204F] [1B27D6E0] 03 [81932029] [6B614252] 04 [14E8CA10] [D476AF10] 05 [78643B04] [C7FB9C48] 06 [4F0CC815] [D147A1DE] 07 [1FEF7752] [961A43C6] 08 [F22BAA81] [90B97603] 09 [49057553] [949B2F1F] 10 [6E1DFE20] [326536CE] 11 [F4CB4C5F] [DED28D48] 12 [5E2E235D] [726F32AE] 13 [E2598314] [E489D62D] 14 [BC3AAC14] [BC9D1DF0] 15 [4CD1019E] [E9EC0DA8] 16 [D3240CE2] [DC3A1077] 17 [F45A1FF8] [D23D103F]
Первый лог не содержит информацию о втором диске и наоборот. Тем не менее, сравнивая с другими, представленными в логах дисками (которые совпадают в двух логах), убеждаемся, что наши два диска отличаются только смещением на 780. Конечно, может так случиться, что диска вообще нет в базе АР. Ну... значит, не повезло. В этом случае, если диски отличаются только смещением, Cuetools это не заметит, и модератор вынужден будет думать, что рипы отличаются (хотя, если диски смещением не отличаются, Cuetools даст совпадающие CRC, и модератор сможет определить повтор). Примечание. С логами XLD ситуация аналогична, поскольку в целом в них содержится та же информация. Однако в них указываются CRC как с учетом нулевых сэмплов, так и без, что часто упрощает сравнение разных рипов. Вот пример лога:
All Tracks Album gain : -4.74 dB Peak : 0.999939 Track 01 Filename : /Volumes/8-Jazz + altro/ Flac/Alessio Menconi, Aldo Romano, Luca Mannutza - Adventures trio (2010) [FLAC] {Abeat JZ 085}/01 - Song For Elis.flac Pre-gap length : 00:02:00 Track gain : -4.43 dB Peak : 0.999939 CRC32 hash (test run) : 04BACED2 CRC32 hash : 04BACED2 CRC32 hash (skip zero) : E55707A1 AccurateRip signature : 2E7594C1
Примечание: Последние версии CueTools определяют также пиковые уровни треков, что удобно использовать при определении повтора, если на руках лог от образа. Однако надо иметь в виду, что вычисление пиковых уровней, сделанное CueTools, может слегка отличаться от результата, полученного ЕАСом (поскольку они вычисляют с разной точностью, и округление может давать разные результаты (скажем, число, близкое к 99,5%, может оказаться и 99%, и 100%).--Автор оригинального текста -mironov_ad
DrStandBy
Кому то в поиске истины, эта статья может оказаться полезной
Быстрый ответ
Вы должны войти в систему, прежде чем совершить данное действие.
